February 21, 2024

Leading Challenging Employees: A Proven 8-Step Approach

As a manager, you may face various challenges while handling difficult employees. It can be pretty demanding to oversee a team of individuals with diverse personalities, work ethics, and attitudes. However, you cannot afford to overlook the impact that challenging employees can have on the overall performance of your team. To ensure that your team performs at their best, it is crucial to proactively address and manage difficult employees. In this blog, we will delve into an 8-step approach proven to effectively lead and bring out the best in challenging employees, providing practical strategies and insights to navigate these complex situations with confidence and success.

Identify the cause of their behavior

When dealing with challenging employees, it is crucial to start by identifying the underlying cause of their behavior. Take the time to carefully assess their actions and evaluate whether the issues lie with their workload, colleagues, or the overall company environment. By understanding the problem comprehensively, including factors such as job dissatisfaction, personal conflicts, or lack of resources, you can determine the most appropriate solutions to support and guide the employee effectively.

For instance, if the employee is experiencing job dissatisfaction, it may be beneficial to provide additional training or resources that can help enhance their skills and job satisfaction. Similarly, if personal conflicts contribute to their behavior, fostering open communication and conflict resolution strategies can be instrumental in resolving the issue. Additionally, making necessary changes to the work environment, such as improving work-life balance or implementing flexible work arrangements, can positively impact employee behavior and overall satisfaction.

Remember, addressing the root cause is critical to fostering a positive and productive work environment where employees feel valued and motivated to contribute their best. Taking the time to delve deeper into the underlying issues and providing tailored solutions can lead to long-term employee performance and satisfaction improvements.

Establish open communication

Creating and maintaining an open line of communication is crucial when effectively leading and managing difficult employees. By actively encouraging these challenging individuals to express their opinions, ideas, and concerns without fearing any negative consequences or retaliation, you are fostering an environment of trust and transparency.

Furthermore, practicing active listening and ensuring clear and concise communication will help these employees feel heard and understood and enable them to participate and engage in the workplace actively. This, in turn, will make it much easier for them to collaborate and cooperate with their colleagues, ultimately leading to a more harmonious and productive work environment.

In addition to that, providing regular feedback and support to these employees can play a significant role in their growth and development. You empower them to overcome challenges and enhance their skills by offering constructive criticism, guidance, and resources. This personalized approach demonstrates your investment in their success and shows you are committed to helping them reach their full potential.

Moreover, it's essential to recognize that each difficult employee may have unique needs and motivations. Taking the time to understand their perspectives, strengths, and weaknesses can help tailor your management approach. By acknowledging their contributions and providing opportunities for professional growth, you can inspire them to strive for excellence and create a positive impact within the organization.

By implementing these strategies, you are addressing the challenges of difficult employees and fostering a culture of inclusivity, growth, and collaboration. This comprehensive approach to leadership and management will benefit the challenging individuals, the entire team, and the organization's overall success.

Set clear and hold them accountable

It is imperative to set clear expectations and define the consequences of falling short to effectively address employees who do not meet the required standards. Establishing precise guidelines and outlining specific performance metrics makes it easier to hold employees accountable for their actions, behaviors, and outcomes. This level of clarity ensures that employees fully comprehend the expectations and helps them understand the direct impact of their performance on the organization's overall success.

Furthermore, fostering a work environment that encourages open communication and constructive feedback can enhance accountability. Regular check-ins, performance evaluations, and coaching sessions provide continuous improvement and growth opportunities. By offering support and guidance, employers can empower their employees to take ownership of their performance and work towards meeting and exceeding the established standards.

It is important to note that accountability should not be seen as a punitive measure but rather as a catalyst for growth and development. Employees are more likely to feel motivated and inspired to strive for improvement by emphasizing the positive impact of meeting expectations. This, in turn, creates a culture of continuous learning and excellence, resulting in a more productive and engaged workforce.

Offer constructive feedback

Offering constructive feedback is an efficient and crucial aspect of effectively managing difficult employees. You can guide them towards continuous improvement and professional growth by providing specific and accurate feedback tailored to their needs. It is essential to ensure that your feedback is timely and frequent, as this allows employees to address their shortcomings promptly and make necessary adjustments. Moreover, it is equally essential to motivate and rally employees by acknowledging and highlighting the progress they have made so far. Recognizing their efforts and achievements creates a supportive environment that encourages their ongoing development.

Additionally, it is essential to communicate the areas that still require improvement clearly and constructively. This enables employees to learn from their mistakes, understand their growth areas, and refine their performance. By setting clear expectations and providing actionable feedback, you empower employees to take ownership of their development and strive for excellence. Remember, constructive feedback is a powerful tool that can positively shape employee behavior and foster a culture of continuous improvement within the workplace, leading to enhanced individual and team performance.

Provide resources and support

One effective way to assist difficult employees is by offering comprehensive training programs tailored to their needs. By providing them with the right resources and support, such as mentoring or coaching, they can enhance their skills and competencies to perform their duties better.

Moreover, creating an inclusive and accommodating work environment that embraces diversity and promotes work-life balance can significantly contribute to fostering a culture of support. This includes enabling necessary changes or accommodations, such as flexible working arrangements or reasonable adjustments, to ensure employees feel valued and empowered. When employees perceive a supportive and understanding atmosphere, they are more likely to be receptive to constructive feedback and suggestions, leading to a more determined work ethic and overall improvement in their performance.

Furthermore, implementing regular check-ins and performance evaluations can help identify any areas where additional support or training may be beneficial. Understanding each employee's unique challenges and motivations can enable managers to provide personalized guidance and assistance.

In addition to training and support, encouraging collaboration and teamwork among employees can foster a sense of camaraderie and shared responsibility. Employees can develop a stronger sense of purpose and a collective commitment to achieving common goals by creating opportunities for employees to work together and learn from each other.

By implementing these comprehensive approaches, organizations can effectively support difficult employees and cultivate a positive work environment that promotes growth and improvement.


Dealing with difficult employees can be a challenging and complex task that every manager may encounter at some point. It requires a thoughtful and strategic approach to effectively address the issues and create a positive work environment.

These eight proven steps can lead your employees toward better performance and foster a more comfortable work environment. First, developing a supportive and challenging atmosphere for the problematic employees is crucial. This means providing them with the necessary resources, guidance, and opportunities for personal growth.

Furthermore, effective communication plays a vital role in dealing with difficult employees. Regular and open dialogues can help identify the root causes of their behavior and provide constructive feedback to address the issues. Holding them accountable for their actions and giving clear expectations can also improve their improvement.

Additionally, it is essential to offer resources and support to help them overcome their challenges. This can include additional training, mentoring, or coaching programs tailored to their needs. You can empower them to overcome obstacles and grow personally and professionally by providing the necessary tools and guidance.

Following these steps can foster a cohesive and highly motivated team. A supportive and challenging environment combined with effective communication and resources will help the problematic employees overcome their challenges and create a positive ripple effect across the entire team.

Remember, dealing with difficult employees is not a one-size-fits-all approach. Each situation may require tailored strategies and a deep understanding of the individual's needs and motivations. However, implementing these steps allows you to navigate the complexities and cultivate a more harmonious and productive work environment.

Return to Unità Blog Home Page